|
|
|
Expansion Joint Sound Attenuation
For
decades we have known that EMSEAL precompressed foam sealants are good at
blocking sound. We just didn't know how good.
(Click here to jump directly to STC/OITC value by product).
We
recently engaged the services of a independent laboratory and were impressed
by a number of things.
We
learned first of all that it is not easy to build a really 'quiet' wall.
And that even when you do, the effectiveness of that wall can be, for all
intents and purposes, negated if it is divided by a structural expansion
joint.
The
lab built several walls for us--STC 56, 68 and 72. Regardless, when they divided that wall with an
unsealed, 2-inch
structural expansion joint, the wall's STC dropped to 17! To the human
ear this is like the wall isn't really there at all.
However, by sealing the joint with a configuration of EMSEAL precompressed
foam sealant, the original STC of the wall could be fully restored.
To
maintain the acoustic integrity of an exterior or interior wall, all EMSEAL
precompressed foam products achieve the highest degree of
sound attenuation by suppressing sound transfer at expansion joint gaps.
As an example, EMSHIELD displays very impressive ratings for STC (Sound
Transmission Class) and OITC (Outdoor-Indoor Transmission Class) in addition to its other features.
WFR2
Performance:
In a wall with a STC 68 rating, WFR2 was tested
to have a STC 62 rating thereby maintaining the sound suppressing
capabilities of the host wall. It also posted an OITC 52 rating.

The impressive acoustic make-up of WFR2 is also matched with these features:
*2-hour Fire Rating per UL 2079
*Watertight Seal
*Color Coordination of both inside and outside sealant faces.
*Easiest installation accomplished without invasive anchors. It is installed from one side
only.
*50%
Movement capability
*Resistance to wind loads well above hurricane force.
With
EMSHIELD, the product
achieves waterproofing, fireproofing, structural movement and soundproofing
all in a single product. When you're searching for an acoustic expansion
joint, you'll find that
EMSEAL products supply acoustic performance in addition to their many other
product features.
Sound Attenuation to Meet Acoustic Requirements
All
EMSEAL precompressed foam products have STC ratings above 50 when tested in
STC 56 or better walls.
Starting at a STC
rating of 52 (based on installation in just one side of a wall) products
range up to a STC rating of 72.
Installed on both sides of a STC 72 wall we have tested COLORSEAL to match
the 72.
Note: All
tests were run by an independent laboratory and were conducted to ASTM E-90--Test
Method for Laboratory Measurement Airborne Sound Transmission Loss of
Building Partitions and Elements.
STC/OITC TEST VALUES by EMSEAL Product:
EMSHIELD:
(4-inch (100mm)
standard depth) |
EMSHIELD:
(custom 6-inch
(150mm)
depth) |
 |
STC 62
OITC 52
*when tested in a STC 68 (OITC 52) wall |
 |
STC 64
OITC 52
*when tested in a STC 68 (OITC 52) wall |
SEISMIC COLORSEAL
- 2 1/2"
(65mm)
standard depth
- one side of wall only |
SEISMIC COLORSEAL
- 2 1/2"
(65mm)
standard depth
- both sides of wall |
 |
STC 52
OITC 38
*when tested in a STC 56 (OITC 38) wall |
 |
STC 68
OITC 51
*when tested in a STC 68 (OITC 52) wall |
| |
|
|
|
SEISMIC COLORSEAL
- custom 4-inch
(100mm) depth
- one side only |
|
 |
STC 54
OITC 38
*when tested in a STC 56 (OITC 38) wall |
COLORSEAL
- 2 1/2"
(65mm)
standard depth
- one side of wall only |
COLORSEAL
- 2 1/2"
(65mm)
standard depth
- both sides of wall |
 |
STC 56
OITC 53*when tested in
a STC 72 (OITC 61) wall |
 |
STC 72
OITC 60*when tested in a STC
72 (OITC 61) wall |
DOUBLE-SIDED SEISMIC COLORSEAL
- 2 1/2"
(65mm)
standard depth
- one side of wall only |
DOUBLE-SIDED SEISMIC COLORSEAL
- 6"
(150mm)
standard depth
- centered in wall section |
 |
STC 54
OITC 38
*when tested in a STC 56 (OITC 38) wall |
 |
STC 62
OITC 52
*when tested in a STC 68 (OITC 52) wall |
| |
|
|
|
BACKERSEAL
- 2 1/2"
(65mm)
standard depth
- one side of wall only
- without field-applied liquid sealant |
BACKERSEAL
- 2 1/2"
(65mm)
standard depth
- both sides of wall
- without field-applied liquid sealant |
 |
STC 53
OITC 49
*when tested in
a STC 68 (OITC 52) wall |
 |
STC 68
OITC 51
*when tested in a STC 68 (OITC 52) wall |
| |
|
|
|
QuietJoint
- 2"
(50mm)
standard depth
- one side of wall only |
QuietJoint
- 2"
(50mm)
standard depth
- both sides of wall |
 |
STC 53
OITC 38
*when tested in
a STC 56(OITC 38) wall |
 |
STC 72
OITC 60
*when tested in a STC 72 (OITC 61) wall |
Interpreting OITC (Outdoor-Indoor Transmission Class)
results
This testing classification is used to specify the
sound transmission loss properties of exterior building
elements such as walls and windows. OITC uses outside noise
sources such as traffic, aircraft and trains to calculate a
this rating. OITC is a commonly used rating for exterior
walls. STC and OITC are independent unrelated tests which do
NOT use a common numbering system for results. A high STC
rating does not necessarily mean that the same wall will
automatically receive a high OITC rating because they are
tested for different acoustic sources and sound frequencies.
However, as general rule of thumb, OITC results usually
display a number that is 70% - 80% of the STC number.
Regardless of your STC or OITC
it is possible to specify an EMSEAL precompressed sealant
that will not degrade the acoustic performance of
the interior or exterior wall or partition.
*The following
explanation of sound transmission class taken largely from
Wikipedia gives an excellent overview of STC and OITC:
Sound Transmission Class
(or STC) is an integer rating of how well a building
partition attenuates airborne sound. In the USA, it is
widely used to rate interior partitions, ceilings/floors,
doors, windows and exterior wall configurations (see ASTM
International Classification E413 and E90). Outside the USA,
the Sound Reduction Index (SRI) ISO standard is used.
The STC number is derived
from sound attenuation values tested at sixteen standard
frequencies from 125 Hz to 4000 Hz. These transmission-loss
values are then plotted on a sound pressure level graph and
the resulting curve is compared to a standard reference
contour.
Acoustical engineers fit these values to the
appropriate TL Curve (or Transmission Loss)
to determine an STC rating. The measurement is accurate for
speech sounds but less so for amplified music, mechanical
equipment noise, transportation noise or any sound with
substantial low-frequency energy below 125 Hz.
Outdoor-Indoor Transmission Class (OITC) is a
standard used for indicating the rate of transmission of
sound between outdoor and indoor spaces in a structure that
considers frequencies down to 80 Hz (Aircraft/Rail/Truck
traffic) and is weighted more to lower frequencies.
STC is roughly the decibel
reduction in noise a partition can provide, abbreviated
'dB'. The dB scale is a logarithmic one and the human ear
perceives a 10dB reduction in sound as roughly halving the
volume - a 40 dB noise subjectively seems half as loud as a
50 dB one.
If an 80dB sound on one side of a
wall/floor/ceiling is reduced to 50dB on the other side,
that partition is said to have an STC of 30.
This number
does not apply across the range of frequencies, since the STC value is derived from a curve-fit of many datapoints.
Any partition will have less TL at lower frequencies. For
example, a wall with an STC of 30 may provide over 40dB of
attenuation at 3000 Hz but only 10dB of attenuation at
125 Hz.
Typical interior walls in
homes (2 sheets of 1/2" drywall on a wood stud frame) have
an STC of about 33. When asked to rate their acoustical
performance, people often describe these walls as "paper
thin". They offer little in the way of privacy. Adding
absorptive insulation (i.e. fiberglass batts) in the wall
cavity increases the STC to 36-39, depending on stud and
screw spacing. Doubling up the drywall in addition to
insulation can yield STC 41-45, provided the wall gaps and
penetrations are sealed properly.
Note that doubling the mass
of a partition does not double the STC. Doubling the mass
(going from two total sheets of drywall to four, for
instance) typically adds 5-6 points to the STC. Breaking the
vibration paths by decoupling the panels from each other
will increase transmission loss much more effectively than
simply adding more and more mass to a monolithic
wall/floor/ceiling assembly.
Structurally decoupling the
drywall panels from each other (by using resilient channels,
steel studs, a staggered-stud wall, or a double stud wall)
can yield an STC as high as 63 or more for a double stud
wall (see table below), with good low-frequency transmission
loss as well. Compared to the baseline wall of STC 33, an
STC 63 wall will transmit only 1/1000 as much sound energy,
seem 88 percent quieter and will render most frequencies
inaudible.
To get to
STC 68 it is necessary to have essentially two walls
back-to-back with an air gap between them, fiberglass
insulation between the studs and a double-layer of
5/8-inch sheet rock on each face.
Due to their high density,
concrete and concrete block walls have good TL values (STC's
in the 40s and 50s for 4-8" thickness) but their weight,
added complexity of construction and poor thermal insulation
tend to be limitations.
[1]
It must be noted that
acoustical performance values such as STC are measured in
specially constructed acoustical chambers and field
conditions such as lack of adequate sealing, outlet boxes,
back-to-back electrical boxes, medicine cabinets, flanking
paths and structure-borne sound can diminish acoustical
performance. The as-built 'field-STC' (FSTC) is usually
lower than the laboratory-measured STC.
Section 1207 of
International Building Code 2006 states that separation
between dwelling units and between dwelling units and public
and service areas must achieve STC 50 (STC 45 if field
tested) for both airborne and structure borne. However, not
all jurisdictions use the IBC 2006 for their building or
municipal code.
In jurisdictions where IBC 2006 is used,
this requirement may not apply to all dwelling units. For
example, a building conversion may not need to meet this
rating for all walls.
In serious cases (for
instance, a bedroom adjacent to a home theater room, and an
inconsiderate nocturnal neighbor, to boot) a partition to
reduce sounds from high-powered home theater or stereo
should ideally be STC 70 or greater, and show good
attenuation at low frequencies. An STC 70 wall can require
detailed design and construction and can be easily
compromised by 'flanking noise', sound traveling around the
partition through the contiguous frame of the structure,
thus reducing the STC significantly. STC 65 to 70 walls are
often designed into luxury multifamily units, dedicated home
theaters, and high end hotels.
The demanding THX reference
standard (a guideline for high-quality audio in movie
soundtracks) requires partitions to achieve 50dB of
attenuation at 63 Hz. Few walls can meet that, as that
requires a wall with an STC of 80 or higher. For all
practical purposes, no sound will be heard on the other side
of the wall with this level of construction.
Sound Transmission Class Examples
|
STC |
What can be heard |
|
25 |
Normal speech can be understood quite easily and
distinctly through wall |
|
30 |
Loud speech can be understood fairly well, normal
speech heard but not understood |
|
35 |
Loud speech audible but not intelligible |
|
40 |
Onset of "privacy" |
|
42 |
Loud speech audible as a murmur |
|
45 |
Loud speech not audible; 90% of statistical
population not annoyed |
|
50 |
Very loud sounds such as musical instruments or a
stereo can be faintly heard; 99% of population not
annoyed. |
|
60+ |
Superior soundproofing; most sounds inaudible |
|
STC |
Partition type |
|
33 |
Single layer of 1/2" drywall on each side, wood
studs, no insulation (typical interior wall) |
|
45 |
Double layer of 1/2" drywall on each side, wood
studs, batt insulation in wall |
|
46 |
Single layer of 1/2" drywall, glued to 6"
lightweight concrete block wall, painted both sides |
|
54 |
Single layer of 1/2" drywall, glued to 8" dense
concrete block wall, painted both sides |
|
55 |
Double layer of 1/2" drywall on each side, on
staggered wood stud wall, batt insulation in wall |
|
59 |
Double layer of 1/2" drywall on each side, on wood
stud wall, resilient channels on one side, batt
insulation |
|
63 |
Double layer of 1/2" drywall on each side, on double
wood/metal stud walls (spaced 1" apart), double batt
insulation |
|
72 |
8" concrete block wall, painted, with 1/2" drywall
on independent steel stud walls, each side,
insulation in cavities |
STC partition ratings taken
from: "Noise Control in Buildings: A Practical Guide for
Architects and Engineers"; Cyril M. Harris, 1994
|